They then all say that they killed themselves out of passion for various reasons. | Cookies help us deliver our Services. A running theme on Family Guy is Brians abysmal track record when it comes to dating. Seth McFarlane's empire is growing - His core property "Family Guy" is no longer its "crown jewel." With the success of American Dad and especially the feature film,Ted, McFarlane no longer needs to keep Family Guy exciting or interesting. Brian's death "reminded people this is still a show where anything can happen despite the fact it's been on for a while," he explained. Chris and Meg regurgitated their The Kingsmen fight in the school cafeteria, Lois was shunned at the grocery store, and Peter was side-eyed by his friends. It is an unfortunate fact that dogs, as a rule, die. You can't eat here.Chris: Uh oh, Meg. ", MacFarlane explained on Twitter that the plot twist was to remind viewers to never take those you love for granted, for they can be gone in a flash., "Oh and hey," he continued. News on Sunday that despite the fact that Brian was a main character for years and the show's general lack of realistic plots, it seemed a more plausible story line for the Griffins' family pet to . Brian Makes Racist Joke (Family Guy) - YouTube 0:00 / 1:56 Brian Makes Racist Joke (Family Guy) 35,754 views Jan 5, 2018 884 Dislike Share Dressrosa 93 subscribers Content owned by Fox No. The social commentary was on point. But a few weeks later, perhaps in response to the viewer backlash, Brian was brought back to life in a Christmas episode that left us all with some residual holiday cheer. ", or "Are there bigger problems in this world than this tweet?" Brian Griffin is a family member on the show Family Guy. An "unlucky" Brian leaped to his death from a balcony at the Vegas Star Hotel as part of a suicide pact with Stewie to avoid an enforcer for a loan shark in "Roads to Vegas". Peter has been known to tease him about his shorter lifespan. Mom shares the ultimate hack to get her kids to eat a wide variety of foods when they only want to eat chicken nuggets, Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO). Brian's popularity became clear when he was killed off inSeason 12's "Life of Brian." It's a sensitivity mob.Meg: It was just a joke.Cafeteria Girl: There's no such things as jokes anymore.Other Cafeteria Boy: Yeah, we live in a post-joke world. The veil of mystery surrounding Brian's death didn't get pulled back until after it was already undone. Distractify is a registered trademark. When reunited with his first owner in "Road to Rhode Island".. To see all content on The Sun, please use the Site Map. I am so far left I'm spinning in circles, you shitheads! Life spans vary depending on breed and circumstance, but by most standards, Brian Griffin had a decent run when the creators of "Family Guy" killed the living snot out of him in the 2013 episode, "Life of Brian." INSTEAD OF KILLING MYSELF, I SHOULD KILL ALL OF YOU! LEAVE ME ALONE! You can't say boo about anyone or anything lest you get labeled which is humorous in itself because the people doing the labeling are also the same people who don't want to be labeled. "And thus endeth our warm, fuzzy holiday lesson: Never take those you love for granted, for they can be gone in a flash," wrote series creator and star Seth MacFarlane in a since-deleted tweet. SEVEN YEARS and people still hold a grudge against Seth MacFarlane because Brian barfed for a full 30 seconds after learning the truth about Ida. You can't just go online and say whatever you want. What happened to Brian on Family Guy? The episode featured Brian getting ran over and killed right in front of his best friend Stewie. The family decides to move on with their lives and buys a new dog, Vinny. 15 Jan 2018. /// I've watched tons of black porn! Shocked, Brian packs up, finds a run-down apartment and settles in. Brian has always seemed like this enlighted guy though these actions come off particularly scummy. Brian discovered that his cocaine habit stemmed from his mother abandoning him for which he saw a therapist. He does not hold steady employment in Quahog, although did once become a substitute teacher at Buddy Cianci Junior High School as well as short stints as a taxi driver in "Deep Throats" and police officer for the Quahog Police Department as a drug sniffing dog in "The Thin White Line". ", "Tales of Former Sports Glory" and "The Jersey Bore" A lot of other families would have just gotten a new dog and moved on. This tribute video is now a relic of the past: That brings the grand total of episodes where Brian remained dead -- not including the episodes in which he was killed and was saved -- to, well,. In response to all the backlash, Family Guy creators decided to bring Brian back to life during a 2013 Christmas episode. MacFarlane normally has to alter his voice while voicingGlenn Quagmire, Peter Griffin, and Stewie Griffin. After Brian gets his teeth completely wrecked, Quagmire (who has his own issues as a character) takes pity on him and pays for his dental treatment. Brian was briefly replaced by a new family dog, Vinnie, voiced by The Sopranos' Tony Sirico. RELATED:Family Guy: 10 Episodes That'll Never Get Old. The Car He Drives And after he renews interest on the account he starts tweeting on a regular basis. As a child, he preferred watching movies like Goodfellas and North By Northwest instead of Home Alone. (It's an incredible burden for a friend to be the only person who knows that someone is suicidal . The D in Apartment 23 The returns from his investments enable him to live comfortably even when he is not working. Season: 16 Episode: 06 Total Episode Count: 295 Prod. In response to all the backlash, Family Guy creators decided to bring Brian back to life during a 2013 Christmas episode. Family Guy 's 300th episode has happened - and it killed off one of . Next Episode. In "Brian: Portrait of a Dog", he seems to have a 'midlife crisis'. "I couldn't live without you so I came back from the future to save your life. In a November 2013 episode of Family Guy, Brian was killed off. At one point in Family Guy, we found out that Quagmire hates Brian for a lot of reasons and this has led to a conflict between the two of them. Be realistic and four-dimensional. This season is awesome because it's finally trying something different than the other seasons. He is voiced by the late Tony Sirico. What does this say about our society? Say it ain't so! In response to all the backlash, Family Guy creators decided to bring Brian back to life during a 2013 Christmas episode. Following the dog's death, Stewie encounters his past self in a shopping mall and remembers that past-Stewie has a time machine hidden in his backpack. "Family Guy" has always been a gushing font of edgy narratives not a lot of other shows would have jumped on "the baby is actively trying to murder his mother" with quite as much dead-eyed focus but even by their standards, slaughtering the family dog seemed uncharacteristically bleak. Brian Hugh Warner was born in Canton, Ohio, on January 5, 1969, the son of Barbara Warner Wyer (died May 13, 2014) and Hugh Angus Warner (died July 7, 2017). In a November 2013 episode of Family Guy, Brian was killed off. Brian gets kicked out of the house for posting an offensive tweet that goes viral. 27 Feb 2023 23:26:44 Seth needs to hire smarter writers with new ideas and more complex character dynamic changes and try making the characters more down to earth and fix the problem of the show's decline over the years. RELATED:Family Guy: Every Road To X Episode, Ranked According To IMDb. Will the Griffins take him back and risk the social implications? Hit the comments and share your thoughts. Brian was hit by a car leaving viewers wondering if he was gone for good or if he. But the sensitivity brigade got hold of it and twisted it around to make it sound like Brian was the biggest racist in the world. FOXs hit animated series Family Guy has been on the air since 1999. Stewie's love of his stuffed bear, Rupert, has led to many touching moments in the series. It was actually funny if you read it for what it was and not for some imaginary message he didn't intend. Brian is the son of two normal dogs namedCoco and Biscuit. He confirms this inSeason 2's thirteenth episode titled "Road to Rhode Island.". The Griffins got the best Christmas present ever on Sunday's episode of Family Guy, when beloved dog Brian who was hit by a car and killed in an episode that aired last month was brought. He pulls up on the driveway of the Griffin home to try and rescue Stewie who happens to be stuck on the roof. He remembers that Brian had a time machine in his backpack at the time of the death and asks Vinne to distract past-Stewie long enough to grab the time machine. According to Seth MacFarlane, the creator of the hit-series, fans created online petitions to bring back the beloved canine. Gotten Brian to talk to someone who could help him with his depression on an ongoing basis. Concurrently with Brian's death, showrunner Seth MacFarlane was on a press tour for another project, Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey, and revealed that most of the questions he fielded were about the dead cartoon dog, rather than his new documentary. Brian eventually gets out of diapers by simply defecating in Mayor West's garden instead, leading Lois to think he is potty-trained. Prior to Brian, the Griffins had another talking dog named Todd, who was put down at the age of 15 due to illness. In Season 18's eleventh episode titled "Short Cuts," the story of him being adopted is reiterated. The (temporary) death of beloved "Family Guy" pet, Brian, caused an uproar among fans who were furious that MacFarlane and writers would kill off, and then seemingly replace, the pooch. In "Airport '07", Brian recalls Stewie beating him up mercilessly in "Patriot Games" and lets him swallow Peter's tobacco spittle in retaliation. via Fandom. And moves into an apartment temporarily. He pops up in the seventh episode of Season 6 titled "The People vs. Martin Sugar." While shopping at a mall, Stewie finds his past self. Luckily for fans, "Family Guy" has already been renewed for two more seasons, with the smart money on further renewals down the road. Everybody hates me! Well, congratulations, you did it! In "Peter's Got Woods", Brian dates a black woman named Shauna Parks, to whom he often nervously rambles about how much he likes African-Americans. In Be Careful What You Fish For, Stewie reports that his daycare teacher is negligent of the kids. According to Seth MacFarlane, Brian died to teach all of us brats at home a valuable lesson. Also, he is shown playing drums in "McStroke". In "Brian: Portrait of a Dog", he refused to perform degrading pet tricks for Peter during a dog show, despite it being necessary to win the money needed to buy the family a new air conditioner. There's a huge difference. The earliest of Vinny's life that has been . I recently saw most of an episode of "Family Guy" in which it was revealed that Brian, the family's dog (who talks and is essentially part of the family), is an atheist. In a post-COVID world, Eric Hasse, a seasoned chef and cook, navigates the hostile kitchen culture and questions the concept of meritocracy as he battles with an exodus of restaur It's a scumbag move from Brian, but he finally gets what he deserves when Quagmire knocks his teeth out, causing him to lose the real estate job. Brian Despite his anthropomorphic intelligence, Brian shares certain traits and shortcomings with real dogs. RELATED: 10 Jokes From Family Guy That Have Already Aged Poorly, The abuse gets worse on Stewies end, as his arm gets dislocated and Brian covers it up. There's no way they'd kill him again, right? like seriously a racist tweet should be the least of Quahog's concerns right now???? His entire outburst on the stoop should have been an eye-opener for the crowd because every word he said was true. Once you think Brian is going to do the right thing, he always seems to disappoint. Stewie is able to travel back to the time of Brians accident and stop it from happening. In "420", he actually does a whole dance to the song A Bag of Weed. Peter is his best friend, despite Brian's vastly superior intelligence. He also defecates outside the house. That remains to be seen. Air date: November 12, 2017 Synopsis: The Griffins force Brian to move out after he posts an offensive tweet that goes viral. He also couldn't control his animal urges for the prized Pewterschmidt dog, Seabreeze. CNN's Brian Stelter mocked for Melania Trump tweet. RT @toonsgowild: That one time where Brian died on family guy and it actually lasted a few episodes . To see all content on The Sun, please use the Site Map. No matter how hard he tried at sounding neutral, someone found something wrong with every word that came out of his mouth. Family Guy is a series that primarily focuses on the Griffin family. It aired on Fox in the United States and Canada on November 24, 2013, and is written by Alex Carter and directed by Joseph Lee.. It has gotten kind of sad and finally peaked in the season fourteen episode, The Heartbreak Dog., RELATED:Family Guy: The 10 Most Annoying Characters, Ranked. The car's license plate reads "BRI-D0G." Or did creator Seth MacFarlane bring him back thanks to the bendable rules of cartoon universes? The Death of Brian Griffin was the temporary departure of the talking dog character from the American animated TV sitcom Family Guy after getting hit by a car in the episode "Life of Brian" which aired in late November 2013. He is overcome with gratitude. Despite the fact that Brian mostly behaves as a human, he exhibits several dog traits too. What is the French language plot outline for The D in Apartment 23 (2017)? In "Brian Goes Back to College", it is revealed that Brian went to Brown University in Rhode Island, but did not graduate. Everybody thought his joke was horrifically offensive, but nobody stopped to think about the responses to his Tweet. Directors Dominic Bianchi (supervising director) James Purdum (supervising director) Julius Wu Writers Seth MacFarlane David Zuckerman Artie Johann Stars Seth MacFarlane (voice) Alex Borstein (voice) So in their conflict, who do you think is in the right? Brian was hit by a car leaving viewers wondering if he was gone for good or if he could miraculously come back thanks to the flexibility in cartoon universes. Everyone joined in on their condemnation of him even going so far as to ostracize the entire Griffin family just because he lived with them. He should get a participation medal for that, shouldn't he? Brian has chosen some form of fame and money over standing up for whats right. He initially tries to hide this condition by blaming it on Stewie, but is discovered when he has a public accident in the grocery store. The reason for him not voting isn't revealed. Mar 4, 2019. After Brian renews his interest in his Twitter account to join a protest, he starts tweeting on a regular basis. However, there is contradicting information in Season 7's fifth episode titled "The Man With Two Brians." His intellectual bent makes it very difficult for him to form romantic relationships with people, leading to his constant failures with women, highlighted in "Valentine's Day in Quahog". Brian Griffin (Last name extended as a courtesy). Family Guy and American Dad! ", Brian responds, "Thank you for saving my life. Kenya. right before boarding a 12-hour flight and similarly having no knowledge of the furor it caused. FOXs hit animated series Family Guy has been on the air since 1999. Family Guy creator Seth MacFarlane took to Twitter on Sunday to address Brian's death and resurrection, writing, "You didn't really think we'd kill off Brian, did you?" (Well, yes, Seth.. What happened to Brian on Family Guy? "Family Guy" shocked its fans Sunday night when it killed off Brian, the Griffin's talking, sarcastic, cocktail-swilling dog voiced by series creator Seth MacFarlane for . Following the death, a new family dog named Vinnie entered the picture. Brian was hit by a car leaving viewers wondering if he was gone for good or if he could miraculously come back thanks to the flexibility in cartoon universes. A running joke on the show is Brian's inability to maintain a human girlfriend. Brian's an intelligent person (animal . This was revealed where he is seen at the library and he is looking for The God Delusion by avowed humanist Richard Dawkins. MacFarlane told The Independent, We were all very surprised in response to all the tweets and online backlash. 17h. If you need to catch up, you canwatch Family Guy onlineright here via TV Fanatic! God is pissed! According to Seth MacFarlane, the creator of the hit-series, fans created online petitions to bring back the beloved canine. As the show has progressed, Brian has regressed. His atheism comes under attack in "Not All Dogs Go To Heaven" when he comes out to the Griffins about his belief or lack of, and Meg, in a drastic effort to convert Brian to Christianity, makes his atheism public knowledge, making him a social outcast until near the end of the episode. Based in Miami, Florida, he started his journalism career in college. So why shouldn't Family Guy stir the pot some more by having Brian question where his medal was for kissing Ida in the first place? Current-day Stewie gets Vinnie to distract past-Stewie long enough to steal the time machine which was broken beyond repair in the episode where Brian dies and is able to travel back to the exact moment of Brian's accident to stop it. Mar 24, 2021. Well, I assure you there are! Social commentary, smart humor, defying the status quo of the show's discontinuity and lack of actual storytelling. The show had existed since 1999, making him at least 14 in real-world years. Years later, Brian gets a text from Dylan saying hes returning to Quahog. However, Stewie is still depressed and tries to ask the Santa at the Quahog Mall to help bring Brian back without luck in "Christmas Guy". ", Brian responds, "Thank you for saving my life. MacFarlane told The Independent, We were all very surprised in response to all the tweets and online backlash. Quagmire hates Brian, so the gesture is seen asa momentous thing. He also possesses various anthropomorphic qualities, such as the ability to speak intelligently, drive a car, and walk bipedally. ", Brian responds, "Thank you for saving my life. For other inquiries, Contact Us. The Sun website is regulated by the Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO), Our journalists strive for accuracy but on occasion we make mistakes. While in the theater, his tweet goes viral and he exits to find an angry mob awaiting him who chase him home. He also chastised Lady and the Tramp for acting in typical dog-like behavior, saying that "that's just what they want you to do." In Play It Again, Brian he finally decides to make a pass at Lois which ends up causing a fight between him and Peter. See production, box office & company info, [the man slowly approaches Brian and punches him]. After the "Christmas Guy" episode of Family Guy brought Brian Griffin back from the dead, Seth MacFarlane took to Twitter to explain exactly why he killed the dog in the first place.. Stewie is able to travel back to the time of Brians accident and stop it from happening. His tweets gather little attention until he makes a racially insensitive remark about a film before seeing Baywatch. Another example of Brian's "humanity" is his attraction to human women; Brian has dated several since the show began, and is deeply in love with Peter's wife. He has invested heavily in the stock market and is able to keep up with IPOs. Family Guy Wiki is a FANDOM TV Community. "Thanks for caring so much about the canine Griffin. When is enough, enough? While the company is responsible for helping keeping homes and businesses warm, Jason is responsible for the creation and growth of analytical capabilities at Weil McLain, and was recognized in 2017 as a "Top 40 Under 40" in the HVAC industry. This is what the show needs to be great again. Sunday night's Christmas-themed installment of "Family Guy" saw the return of the much-beloved canine Brian Griffin . & # x27 ; s life that has been on the Griffin Family on Family Guy Brian! Other seasons moments in the stock market and is able to keep up with IPOs with Brians... Griffins take him back and risk the social implications this world than this tweet? time! Brian to talk to someone who could help him with his depression on an ongoing basis courtesy! To be stuck on the driveway of the furor it caused a therapist Never. Pops up in the seventh episode of Family Guy onlineright here via TV Fanatic should have been an eye-opener the. One time where Brian died to teach all of you this Season is awesome because it finally. Interest in his Twitter account to join a protest, he seems to disappoint flight similarly... Became clear when he was killed off seriously a racist tweet should be the person... Habit stemmed from his mother abandoning him for which he saw a.. The Site Map Tony Sirico some imaginary message he did n't intend for posting an offensive tweet goes., Family Guy is Brians abysmal track record when it comes to dating n't here.Chris. Stewie finds his past self information in Season 18 's eleventh episode ``... Read it for what it was actually funny if you read it for what it was and not some... Car, and Stewie Griffin to catch up, finds a run-down Apartment and settles in in... Thought his joke was horrifically offensive, but nobody stopped to think about the Griffin. Family member on the driveway of the house for posting an offensive tweet goes!: Uh oh, Meg makes a racially insensitive remark about a film before seeing Baywatch or `` Are bigger..., Rupert, has led to many touching moments in the theater, his tweet goes viral Stewie that... Rules of cartoon universes Sugar. 's popularity became clear when he is asa! Brian has always seemed like this enlighted Guy though these actions come off particularly scummy episode, according...: 10 Episodes that 'll Never get Old with his depression on ongoing. 18 's eleventh episode titled `` the People vs. Martin Sugar. risk the social implications Ranked to. Gesture is seen at the library and he is seen asa momentous thing to! Up on the stoop should have been an eye-opener for the D in Apartment 23 ( 2017 ) until. Defecating in Mayor West 's garden instead, leading Lois to think the! Of Season 6 titled `` Road to X episode, Ranked according to Seth MacFarlane Brian. Eleventh episode titled `` Short Cuts, '' the story of him being adopted is reiterated ability to speak,. Brian Stelter mocked for Melania Trump tweet simply defecating in Mayor West 's garden instead, leading to. Whatever you want best friend Stewie he has invested heavily in the seventh episode of Family Guy, responds... They killed themselves out of diapers by simply defecating in Mayor West 's what did brian tweet on family guy instead, leading Lois think! An angry mob awaiting him who chase him home named Vinnie entered the picture the show to. Fifth episode titled `` the People vs. Martin Sugar. to see all content the. Him being adopted is reiterated stuffed bear, Rupert, has led to many moments. His best friend Stewie joke on the air since 1999 able to keep up IPOs... Always seems to have a 'midlife crisis ' horrifically offensive, but nobody stopped to think the! Kill all of you that dogs, as a courtesy ) seems to have 'midlife... Came out of the Griffin home to try and rescue Stewie who happens be... 2013 episode of Family Guy: every Road to Rhode Island..... He should get a participation medal for that, should n't he catch up, finds run-down. From his mother abandoning him for which he saw a therapist once you think is... Drives and after he renews interest on the air since 1999 lack of actual.... For caring so much about the canine Griffin control his animal urges for the because... Reason for him not voting is n't revealed until he makes a racially insensitive remark about film. Right thing, he exhibits several dog traits too preferred watching movies like Goodfellas and North by instead... He Drives and after he renews interest on the driveway of the it... Having no knowledge of the show 's discontinuity and lack of actual storytelling gone for good if... The Independent, We were all very surprised in response to all the backlash, Family Guy, was. Neutral, someone found something wrong with every word he said was.... `` life of Brian. bring him back thanks to the time of Brians accident and stop it from.! Discovered that his cocaine habit stemmed from his investments enable him to live even! What is the son of two normal dogs namedCoco and Biscuit mystery surrounding Brian 's vastly superior intelligence later... Actually lasted a few Episodes Family member on the air since 1999 Episodes that 'll Never get Old to. Stewie reports that his daycare teacher is negligent of the Griffin home to try and Stewie. Seen asa momentous thing has happened - and it actually lasted a few Episodes that primarily focuses on show! Back and risk the social implications Brians accident and stop it from happening is his best friend, despite 's. Based in Miami, Florida, he started his journalism career in.... Season is awesome because it 's finally trying something different than the other seasons Stewie finds his past self nobody! Brian responds, `` Thank you for saving my life the car he Drives and he. `` life of Brian. MacFarlane, Brian gets a text from Dylan saying returning! Is the French language plot outline for the prized Pewterschmidt dog,.... Gather little attention until he makes a racially insensitive remark about a film before seeing Baywatch Stewie! Is shown playing drums in `` McStroke '' again, right, Vinny hes returning to.. Say it ain & # x27 ; s love of his mouth Guy, Brian responds, `` Thank for... Extended as a human, he is looking for the God Delusion by avowed humanist Dawkins... Shorter lifespan a 12-hour flight and similarly having no knowledge of the house for posting an offensive tweet that viral!, Vinnie, voiced by the Sopranos ' Tony Sirico cnn & # x27 ; s love of stuffed... Right thing, he preferred watching movies like Goodfellas and North by instead. A valuable lesson commentary, smart humor, defying the status quo of the kids for caring so much the! Show had existed since 1999 posting an offensive tweet that goes viral, but nobody stopped to think about responses... The fact that Brian mostly behaves as a human girlfriend in Apartment 23 the returns from his mother him... In front of his mouth Guy has been after Brian renews his interest his... Namedcoco and Biscuit: 16 episode: 06 Total episode Count: 295 Prod his tweets gather attention. A car leaving viewers wondering if he was briefly replaced by a new dog, Seabreeze I 'm spinning circles! Extended as a child, he actually does a whole dance to the bendable rules of cartoon universes car viewers. Florida, he started his journalism career in college Brian despite his anthropomorphic intelligence, Brian shares traits... Life of Brian. veil of mystery surrounding Brian 's vastly superior intelligence killed! Seems to disappoint tweeting on a regular basis for Melania Trump tweet home to try and rescue who... Traits too wrong with every word he said was true a human girlfriend always seems to.! Him home and he is not working Seth MacFarlane, the creator of the,... To join a protest, he seems to have a 'midlife crisis ' for so... Rupert, has led to many touching moments in the stock market and is able to travel back the... Death, a new Family dog named what did brian tweet on family guy entered the picture and punches him ] entered the picture,! Show 's discontinuity and lack of actual storytelling to teach all of brats. Brian to talk to someone who could what did brian tweet on family guy him with his depression on an ongoing basis pulls up on Griffin. Regular basis despite the fact that Brian mostly behaves as a human he! I came back from the future to save your life need to catch up, finds a Apartment! '', he actually does a whole dance to the time of Brians accident and stop it happening. Has regressed and stop it what did brian tweet on family guy happening ongoing basis intelligently, drive a car, and walk.. N'T intend shorter lifespan he starts tweeting on a regular basis seemed like this enlighted Guy though these come. Fame and money over standing up for whats right person ( animal in this world than this tweet? 's. Dog traits too dog, Vinny I could n't live without you so I came back from the to... Titled `` Short Cuts, '' the story of him being adopted is reiterated a running on! Finds his past self to Seth MacFarlane, Brian responds, `` Thank you for saving my life Cuts ''. Keep up with IPOs his tweet goes viral and he exits to find an angry awaiting... Briefly replaced by a car leaving viewers wondering if he was killed off ( Last name extended a. Rhode Island. `` good or if he future to save your life or he! Shocked, Brian was killed off MacFarlane, the creator of the kids created online petitions to bring Brian to. Burden for a friend to be stuck on the air since 1999, making him least! It actually lasted a few Episodes 's vastly superior intelligence if he was gone for good or he...